“Hannah listed our Carmel home at a number we initially thought was too aggressive. We had 11 showings the first weekend and closed $22,000 over asking. She knew the Clay Township comps better than anyone we interviewed.”
Rebecca M.
Carmel, IN
Broker-led team that actually returns your calls. 280+ closings since 2016, 94% of listings sell at or above asking, and we don't double-end deals to the detriment of either side.
Same-day callback from a licensed broker — not an assistant.
By calling, you may receive one automated text if unanswered. Reply STOP to opt out. Privacy · Terms
9
Years in Business
4.9★
Customer Rating
94%
Sell At/Above Asking
IN
Broker Licensed & MIBOR
From quick fixes to full installations — quality work, transparent pricing.
How We Work
Your goals, timeline, neighborhood, budget. No pressure — just understanding what a good outcome looks like for you.
Sellers: comps, staging, professional photography. Buyers: pre-approval coaching, neighborhood deep-dives, lender referral.
Showings, offer crafting, inspection coordination, contract negotiation — handled by your licensed broker, not a junior agent.
Title coordination, walkthrough, signing day. We're at the closing table with you — keys in hand, deal done right.
Testimonials
“Hannah listed our Carmel home at a number we initially thought was too aggressive. We had 11 showings the first weekend and closed $22,000 over asking. She knew the Clay Township comps better than anyone we interviewed.”
Rebecca M.
Carmel, IN
“First-time buyer and I was nervous about everything. Hannah's team walked me through pre-approval, neighborhood comps, the inspection — they attended every step. I never felt like I was being rushed into an offer.”
Jennifer T.
Fishers, IN
“We relocated from Denver and used Hannah for buyer rep. She did video walkthroughs of seven Zionsville neighborhoods before we flew in, lined up 14 showings across two days, and we were under contract by the end of the trip.”
Sarah K.
Zionsville, IN
The Person Behind the Company
Broker & Founder · License #IN-PB-RB14048992
Hannah Whitaker founded Circle City Realty Group after 11 years inside large national brokerages, where the pressure to double-end deals and steer clients toward in-house lenders quietly conflicted with the broker's fiduciary duty. Hannah built Circle City with one rule: we don't double-end, we don't take lender referral fees, and the broker who signs your listing is the broker who negotiates your contract — not a junior agent the firm hands the file to.
"Represent one side of every deal — fully. Negotiate the contract ourselves. No hidden referral economics."
Get Started
Thinking of listing in Carmel? First-time buyer in Fishers? Want a home valuation? Drop your details and a licensed broker will reach out within one business day.
We've received your request. A licensed broker will reach out within one business day. Want to speak now? Call (555) 178-9900.
Our Guarantee
If your listing doesn't get a serious offer in 45 days at our suggested price, we cut commission by 1%.
Where We Operate
We cover a 35-mile radius around Indianapolis — including Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, Westfield, and more.
Circle City Realty Group
35-mile coverage area
The questions clients ask before they pick up the phone.
Standard listing: 5-6% total, split with buyer's agent (we offer pricing tiers based on services included). Buyer representation: free to you — paid out of the seller's side. Full pricing on our 'About Our Fees' page; no hidden numbers.
In the Indianapolis market right now, our listings average 11 days on market vs. the MLS median of 24. The difference is pricing strategy and professional listing prep — most overpriced listings sit and lose negotiation leverage.
Yes — and the builder almost always covers the buyer's-side commission, so it's free for you. We've represented buyers at every major builder in Hamilton, Hendricks, and Johnson counties.